Court Nullifies TSC Internship Programme: Victory for Junior Secondary School Teachers as Court of Appeal Orders Permanent Employment Terms

Share

The Kenyan education landscape has been rocked by a monumental legal decision in March 2026 that could redefine the employment terms for tens of thousands of educators. The Court of Appeal has officially upheld the nullification of the Teachers Service Commission (TSC) internship programme, declaring the policy of hiring qualified teachers as interns null and void.

This ruling comes at a critical time when the country is navigating the staffing of Junior Secondary Schools (JSS). For the 44,000+ teachers currently serving as interns, this isn’t just a legal victory; it is a fight for professional dignity, equal pay, and job security. Education Cabinet Secretary Julius Ogamba has confirmed that the government is now studying the “financial and budgetary implications” of complying with this historic directive.

The Core of the Dispute: Why the Court Intervened

The petition against the TSC, originally brought forward by the Forum for Good Governance and Human Rights, centered on a fundamental argument: Why should fully qualified, registered, and licensed teachers be hired as “interns” to perform the same duties as their colleagues on permanent terms?

Justice Byram Ongaya of the Employment and Labour Relations Court (ELRC) initially set the stage in 2024, observing that the TSC’s mandate is to employ registered teachers on terms that are not discriminatory. In March 2026, the Court of Appeal solidified this stance, ending years of legal “reprieves” and stay orders that had kept teachers in limbo.

Key Findings of the Court Ruling:

  • Violation of Right to Fair Labour Practices: The court held that subjecting trained professionals to internship stipends while they carry a full workload is exploitative.

  • Discriminatory Terms: The disparity in pay—where an intern earns a fraction of what a permanent teacher earns for the same work—was ruled illegal.

  • Lack of Legal Framework: The court found that the TSC failed to exhibit statutory or policy arrangements that allow it to hire qualified professionals as “interns” rather than full employees.

The Impact on Junior Secondary Schools (JSS)

Since the inception of JSS under the Competency-Based Curriculum (CBC) framework, the government has heavily relied on intern teachers to plug massive staffing gaps. These teachers have been the backbone of the transition, often working in under-resourced schools with high student-to-teacher ratios.

With the internship programme now declared “null and void,” the government faces a logistical challenge. If the internship contracts are illegal, the TSC is technically required to either confirm these teachers on Permanent and Pensionable (P&P) terms or risk a total collapse of the JSS learning system.

Financial Implications: The Billion-Shilling Question

The ruling has significant budgetary implications for the National Treasury. Currently, intern teachers in primary schools receive a stipend of roughly Ksh 15,000, while those in secondary schools receive Ksh 20,000. In contrast, entry-level teachers on permanent terms (Job Group C2) earn significantly more when allowances and benefits are included.

To transition all 44,000 interns to permanent terms, the government will need to allocate billions of additional shillings. Senator Samson Cherargei and other lawmakers have already begun questioning whether the Supplementary Budget will include funds to cater for this mass transition.

The Human Element: Voices from the Ground

For many teachers, the “intern” tag felt like a betrayal of their years of study. Many JSS interns have reported taking home as little as Ksh 13,000 after statutory deductions like the Housing Levy and NSSF.

“We are not students; we are professionals,” said a representative from the JSS teachers’ association. “We prepare lesson plans, we grade exams, and we manage classrooms. Doing all that for a ‘stipend’ while our colleagues get full salaries is heartbreaking.”

The ruling also addresses the “unfair termination” of over 700 teachers who were sacked in 2024 for participating in strikes. The court’s current stance gives these educators renewed hope for reinstatement and compensation.

What Happens Next? TSC’s Response and the Road Ahead

The Teachers Service Commission, led by CEO Nancy Macharia, is currently consulting with the Ministry of Education. While the government previously argued that they lacked the budget to confirm all interns at once, the 2026 ruling leaves little room for further delay.

Potential Scenarios:

  1. Immediate Confirmation: The government bows to pressure and converts all current internships to permanent contracts in the 2026/2027 Financial Year.

  2. Phased Absorption: TSC may propose a fast-tracked phased approach, though this may face further legal hurdles if deemed discriminatory against those served longer.

  3. New Career Progression Guidelines: CS Julius Ogamba has hinted at new policy changes, including making Junior Schools independent institutions with their own principals, which may coincide with new hiring structures.

SEO Section: Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What did the court rule about the TSC internship in 2026?

The Court of Appeal upheld the ruling that the TSC internship programme is illegal and unconstitutional. The commission is now required to hire qualified teachers on permanent terms.

2. Will JSS interns be confirmed to permanent and pensionable terms?

Yes, the ruling mandates the transition. Education CS Julius Ogamba has stated the government is determining the financial extent to ensure they “abide by that court ruling.”

3. How many teachers are affected by the TSC internship ruling?

Approximately 44,000 to 46,000 intern teachers, primarily stationed in Junior Secondary Schools across Kenya, are directly impacted.

4. What is the current salary of a TSC intern vs. permanent teacher?

Interns receive between Ksh 15,000 and Ksh 20,000 (stipend). Permanent teachers in equivalent roles earn upwards of Ksh 35,000 to Ksh 50,000 including various allowances.

Expert Analysis: Why This Matters for Kenya’s Education Future

This ruling is a “reset button” for the Ministry of Education. It forces the government to stop using temporary solutions for teacher shortages. For the CBC to succeed, the teachers delivering the curriculum must be motivated and secure.

If the government fails to address this ruling promptly, we may see a wave of industrial action. The ball is now in the court of the TSC and the National Treasury to find a sustainable way to honor the court’s decision while keeping schools running.

 A Turning Point for Labor Rights

The nullification of the TSC internship programme is a victory for labor rights in Kenya. It reinforces the principle of “equal pay for equal work” and reminds state agencies that they must operate within the boundaries of the Constitution. As the dust settles, all eyes remain on the TSC headquarters to see how quickly they will move to issue permanent appointment letters.